In the critical discussion portion of the book review essay, you'll evaluate the contribution the text has made to the associated discipline/field. In order to complete this portion, you should ask yourself how the book advances the debate that's discussed in the text. This requires you to identify the problems or controversies addressed in the text and assess whether or not the book has made a valuable contribution to the field (or simply whether or not the author has adequately supported his/her thesis). You will need to use evidence from the text in order to support your argument . This means you should reference quotes from the book throughout the essay.
An article review is both a summary and an evaluation of another writer's article. Teachers often assign article reviews to introduce students to the work of experts in the field. Experts also are often asked to review the work of other professionals. Understanding the main points and arguments of the article is essential for an accurate summation. Logical evaluation of the article's main theme, supporting arguments, and implications for further research is an important element of a review. Here are a few guidelines for writing an article review.